On Thursday, the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) took the long-expected action of invoking its authority to regulate cigars and other types of tobacco. We’ll be exploring why the action would be disastrous for handmade cigars in he coming days and weeks, but first it’s important to get an understanding of what exactly has been proposed.
In 2009, Congress passed, and President Obama signed, the Tobacco Control Act, which directed the FDA to regulate cigarettes, as well as cigarette tobacco, roll-your-own tobacco, and smokeless tobacco. Under current regulations, all new cigarettes require FDA approval before they can be sold, and flavored cigarettes (with the exception of menthol) are banned for sale in the U.S.
The bill also authorized the FDA to regulate other types of tobacco (including cigars), but leaves it up to the agency through its rule-making mechanisms to decide if it will regulate tobacco other than cigarettes and, if so, what form that regulation will take. In order to assert its authority to regulate cigars, the FDA must go through a federal rule-making process.
Last Thursday, the FDA took a big step towards regulating Other Tobacco Products (OTP) including cigars, by proposing to assert the FDA’s authority to regulate OTP by deeming them under the Tobacco Control Act. According to the document, “once a tobacco product is deemed, FDA may put in place ‘restrictions on the sale and distribution of a tobacco product,’ including age-related access restrictions and advertising and promotion restrictions, if FDA determines the restrictions are appropriate for the protection of the public health.”
Specifically, this means the following six regulations (that currently apply to cigarettes) would also apply to the additional products subject to the FDA’s deeming, including cigars:
(1) Enforcement action against products determined to be adulterated and misbranded; (2) required submission of ingredient listing and reporting of harmful and potentially harmful constituents (HPHCs) for all tobacco products; (3) required registration and product listing for all tobacco products; (4) prohibition against the use of modified risk descriptors (e.g., “light,” “low,” and “mild” descriptors) and claims unless FDA issues an order permitting their use; (5) prohibition on the distribution of free samples (same as for cigarettes); and (6) pre-market review requirements.
Some of these would cause significant disruption in the way new cigars are brought to market with costs of compliance ultimately passed on to consumers. While each of the six actions would cause some upheaval, experts seem to agree the requirement for FDA approval of new products would completely change the way the handmade cigar world works.
The FDA Approval Process
When finalized, the law would require every new tobacco product, including cigars, introduced after February 15, 2007, to be approved by the FDA. Products currently on the market but introduced after that date could be sold while the FDA rules on approval.
The FDA approval process has two methods to approve new products (which includes changes to existing products). Completely new products would require extreme amounts of scientific data and research, which would effectively stop new products from coming to market. The other route to approval is by proving that a new product is substantially equivalent to a product either introduced prior to February 15, 2007, or approved by the FDA since.
“Substantial equivalence” sounds like a process that should be relatively easy for approving new cigars—after all new cigars are generally just new blends of same types of tobacco that are already used in existing cigars—but the FDA approval process for cigarettes has demonstrated that it is anything but easy or quick. In fact, it’s effectively impossible. To date, the agency has only ruled on 34 products (approving 17 and rejecting 17) of the roughly 4,000 pending applications.
With hundreds of new cigars coming out every year (many thousands if each size is considered a new product) there is little reason to think the FDA approval process would do anything but effectively halt the introduction of new cigars. The 150 or so FDA employees tasked with approvals have only managed to respond to fewer than 1 in 100 applications since 2009, and there is no extra budget for dealing with the increased applications that would come from this rule.
Option for Limited ‘Premium Cigar’ Exemption
In response to lobbying from premium cigar advocacy organizations and others (including cigar allies in Congress) the FDA proposed two options for regulating cigars. The first—opposed by cigar associations—would subject all cigars to the burdensome regulations described above, while “Option 2″ would create an exemption for cigars defined by the FDA as “Premium Cigars.”
While Cigar Rights of America and others have long promoted legislation to exempt traditional and premium cigars from FDA regulation, the definition proposed by the FDA under “Option 2″ is far more restrictive than the one contained in the “Traditional Cigar Manufacturing and Small Business Jobs Preservation Act.” The FDA deeming document proposed eight criteria (all of which must be met) in order for a cigar to meet the “Premium Cigar” exemption under this option:
(1) Is wrapped in whole tobacco leaf; (2) contains a 100 percent leaf tobacco binder; (3) contains primarily long-filler tobacco; (4) is made by combining manually the wrapper, filler, and binder; (5) has no filter, tip, or non-tobacco mouthpiece and is capped by hand; (6) has a retail price (after any discounts or coupons) of no less than $10 per cigar (adjusted, as necessary, every 2 years, effective July 1st, to account for any increases in the price of tobacco products since the last price adjustment); (7) does not have a characterizing flavor other than tobacco; and (8) weighs more than 6 pounds per 1,000 units.
Item 8 (“6 pounds per thousand”) is identical to a provision in the industry-supported legislation (and would effectively mean that a cigar four inches with a 38 ring gauge would definitely meet that criteria). Criteria 1-5 differ slightly from the legislation, which is designed to protect American jobs in the cigar industry (which allows for U.S.-made cigars to use homogenized binders as long as the wrapper is applied by hand).
Number 7, the prohibition on “characterizing flavor other than tobacco” raises significant issues. Not only would an infused cigar presumably not meet the exemption even if there is no scientific reason for excluding them, but the FDA has thus far refused to say what the definition of “characterizing flavor” is, and wouldn’t even say if aging tobacco in cedar qualifies. Given traditional techniques like barrel-aging tobacco, using betunes with wine, and newer developments like using maple or hickory in the curing process, this would surely stifle innovation in the industry.
By far the most threatening to the handmade cigar industry is item 6, which says for a cigar to meet the “Premium Cigar” exemption it must retail for $10 or more. The cigar industry has long taken the position that handmade traditional or premium cigars are about the production process, not about any arbitrary cost threshold, and there is no reason to believe that the health implications of a handmade $4 cigar are any different from a $10 one.
Estimates vary about how much of the handmade cigar market would fail to meet the $10 retail price, but a survey produced by Gary Griffith of Emilio Cigars of 26 stores in four states with varying demographics and tobacco tax rates found that only around 15% of cigars sold were above that price, while 60% of cigars sold in the $6-9.99 range and the remainder sold for less than $6.
As of now, these are the rules the FDA has proposed; they are not yet finalized. Currently, the FDA is accepting public comments on the proposals for 75 days ending July 9, after which it will consider the public comments and likely then issue a final rule.
It will be critical that cigar smokers use the public comment period to make their voices heard, especially to advocate for an exemption for premium cigars that does not arbitrarily eliminate a significant percentage of cigars currently being sold based on a price. Otherwise, the innovation and creativity that makes the handmade cigar industry so great will come to a grinding halt.
In the coming days and weeks, we’ll have more to say about this critically important issue, including suggested points to make when you file a public comment. So please check back often and consider signing up for our free email newsletter for critical updates and reminders.
photo credits: Stogie Guys /Gary Griffith