The Stogie Guys

Each Saturday and Sunday we’ll post a Quick Smoke: not quite a full review, just our brief verdict on a single cigar of “buy,” “hold,” or “sell.”

This slightly-tapered perfecto includes 44-year-old Pelo de Oro pre-embargo Cuban filler tobacco from the former DWG Cigar Company in Lima, Ohio. It is finished with a shiny Cameroon wrapper. Only 40,000 were made (the one I smoked was number 28,573). It’s a distinctly medium-bodied smoke with nutty flavors, leather, and loads of cedar. The taste is consistent, though enjoyable throughout, and the Liberty 2006 has excellent construction with a white ash.

Verdict = Buy.

–Patrick S

photo credit: Stogie Guys

Mederos Cigars is a new outfit that debuted at the 2009 IPCPR Trade Show in New Orleans. Named for Cuban-born Carlos Mederos, the cigars are rolled in Estelí, Nicaragua, using tobacco from Mederos’ Estelí farm.

Mederos’ story reads like the history of so many cigar makers of Cuban descent. In Cuba, Carlos worked alongside his father and grandfather in a cigar factory but eventually left the island in 1983 to make a better life for his family in the United States. Never forgetting his cigar roots, he ended up purchasing his own farm in Estelí in 2006.

The result of his journey is a Nicaraguan puro that comes in four sizes, all with a ring gauge of 50: Fifty 1 (robusto), Fifty 2 (toro), Fifty 3 (torpedo), and Fifty 4 (double corona). For this review I smoked a few samples of the five-inch robusto size.

It features a corojo wraper from Jalapa, Nicaragua, that is slightly dry in appearance with many small veins. The robusto feels firm to the touch and well-constructed.

Once lit, I find a medium-bodied smoke with distinct sweet cedar flavors and a cinnamon spice. While it”s not overly complex, it does have a sweet-and-spicy characteristic commonly found in a Cameroon-wrapped smoke.

With the exception of the defining flavors growing slightly stronger as the cigar progresses, there is little variation from start to finish. Fortunately, construction is excellent with a stable gray ash and  an easy draw.

Available for around $6, there’s a lot to like about the straight-forward flavors of the Mederos Fifty 1. No, you won’t be blown away by complexity, but you will appreciate its pleasant and balanced profile.

Mr. Mederos should be proud of his first creation, which earns a most respectable rating of three and a half stogies out of five.

[To read more StogieGuys.com cigar reviews, please click here.]

–Patrick S

photo credit: Stogie Guys

Since I wrote about it last March, Buffalo Trace has become my go-to sipping bourbon. It is complex, affordable, approachable, and downright delicious with notes of vanilla and honey. Highly recommended.

So, on my most recent trip to the liquor store, I decided to try my luck with another product of the Buffalo Trace distillery, which is located on the banks of the Kentucky River near Frankfort. My choices included Blanton’s, W.L. Weller, Old Charter, and Van Winkle—a lineup that has helped Buffalo Trace win more international awards since 1990 than any other North American operation, not to mention Whiskey Magazine’s “Distiller of the Year” award in 2005 and 2007.

Remembering some word-of-mouth praise, I decided on a bottle of Eagle Rare Single Barrel and purchased it for just under $25. This brand was introduced in 1975 as a 101-proof bourbon in the Seagram family of liquors. Then, in 1989, it was sold and moved to Buffalo Trace where the multi-barrel, more potent original recipe was re-blended in 2005.

Today, Eagle Rare is offered in two varieties: a 17-year-old “Antique Collection” that sells for upwards of $70 per bottle, and a standard 10-year-old. Both, according to the back of the bottle, honor a creature that symbolizes the “freedom, spirit, and independence of the individual.”

Sampling the 10 year variety, I find a golden bourbon that smells of sweet oak and leather as it is poured from its slender bottle. The aroma is soft yet bright with background notes of melon and banana. But first impressions can be misleading.

The taste, as you might have guessed, is decidedly more powerful than expected with a well-rounded profile of sweet corn, charred steak, and raisin. Oily then blazing, the finish of toast and nuts drags for what seems like days. Bourbon enthusiasts who can embrace black pepper flavors will be captivated while others may be scared off after the first sip.

While many will no doubt disagree, I happen to think Eagle Rare is a bit too powerful to sip on its own. Paired with a full-bodied cigar, however, it suits nicely. Good complements include the Illusione 2, PG Soirée Connoisseur, Patel Bros. Toro, and the Nestor Miranda Oscuro Ruky. Proceed with caution.

–Patrick A

photo credit: Stogie Guys

A victim of the cigar boom that was later bought up and revived by Cigars International, 5 Vegas (pronounced “Cinco Vegas”) has a loyal following for its consistency and value. Several of the brand’s lines, including the maduro-wrapped Series ‘A’ and the Sumatra-wrapped Classic, are considered reliable everyday smokes for cigar enthusiasts far and wide.

A top seller among them is the Gold. This Honduran-made smoke is, according to Cigars International, evidence that “milder cigars still rule…despite the pomp and circumstance surrounding full-bodied, powerhouse cigars these days.”

Packaged in trapezoidal prism-shaped boxes of 20, Gold features a long filler of five-year-old Cuban-seed tobaccos from Nicaragua and Honduras and a Honduran binder. It is draped in a smooth Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper with an ochre hue and few veins

Seven sizes are available, including a box-pressed format called “Double Nickel” and a small smoke called “Nuggets.” Opting for a more traditional vitola, I chose the Torpedo (6 x 54) for this review. It is a predominantly handsome yet listless-looking cigar with a delicate aroma of hay and sharp cap that’s prone to minor tears.

After toasting the foot, the Torpedo shows promise with a flavor of creamy almond and a surprisingly peppery finish. The profile, although a tad salty, is nicely balanced and the resting smoke is subtle and appealing.

Another positive trait that quickly emerges is the Torpedo’s effortless draw. Each puff is noticeably clear, producing rich, voluminous billows of white smoke—likely contributing to the cigar’s relatively quick burn.

Approaching the midway point, the taste settles into one of less pepper and more cream. A caramel-like sweetness is also present, adding a bit of depth to the mild smoke. Then, as the straight burn progresses, the finale is marked by an even milder flavor that makes specific notes difficult to pick up.

On the whole, while I may not agree with the Gold blend’s more enthusiastic reviews, I concur that this an good value—especially for only $65 per box or $18 per five-pack.

The Torpedo works well in the morning, and its excellent construction makes it a prime candidate for the golf course. Impressed but not enthralled, I give the 5 Vegas Gold Torpedo three and a half stogies out of five.

[To read more StogieGuys.com cigar reviews, please click here.]

–Patrick A

photo credit: Stogie Guys

Each Saturday and Sunday we’ll post a Quick Smoke: not quite a full review, just our brief verdict on a single cigar of “buy,” “hold,” or “sell.”

The Le Bijou 1922 was created to honor Don Pepin’s father. Featuring a smooth, dark brown Ecuadorian habano oscuro wrapper, the Petit Robusto (4.5 x 50) is a beautiful cigar. Construction is flawless with no soft spots and a perfectly applied triple cap. The cigar offers an easy draw that produces a good volume of smoke and flavors of earth, pepper, and a hint of mint with a sweet, creamy finish. But while nice, the taste isn’t very deep, leaving something missing. I also had to maintain the burn with my torch a couple times to keep the cigar from tunneling. At $7 per stick, this particular My Father Le Bijou Petit Robusto seemed promising but was ultimately disappointing.

Verdict = Sell.

–Patrick M

photo credits: Stogie Guys

Each Saturday and Sunday we’ll post a Quick Smoke: not quite a full review, just our brief verdict on a single cigar of “buy,” “hold,” or “sell.”

With a brand name that harkens the gift of fire to mortals and a price in excess of $20, this Cameroon-wrapped cigar has a lot of live up to. It delivers. The well-constructed blend, crafted by Carlito Fuente, sports a smooth and chalky flavor of roasted cashew, sweet cedar, and tangy leather. Its top-notch balance makes the God of Fire Carlito 2006 Double Robusto a treat for rare occasions.

Verdict = Buy.

–Patrick A

photo credit: Stogie Guys

Since I reviewed it in May, the Cubano Claro Toro has been a staple in my humidor for its affordable price, unique flavor, and solid construction. Now it seems appropriate to examine another size in this blend: the seven inch by 48 ring gauge Churchill.

It, too, is made by Cuban Crafters from desflorado tobacco, a difficult and finicky leaf that’s often reserved for rare and expensive cigars. The desflorado process requires the buds on tobacco plants to be cut off before they flower to give the leaves a rich, smooth taste. Then, in the case of Cubano Claro, the best leaves are hand selected from the tops of each plant to create the Connecticut desflorado wrapper for this line, a project that was four years in the making.

But don’t let the phrase “Connecticut wrapper” fool you. With a relatively dark complexion and a reddish-yellow hue, this cigar doesn’t look, smell, or feel like a traditional Connecticut leaf. It is highlighted by a clean cap, few noticeable veins or seams, and a pre-light aroma of salty hay.

Like the Toro, which also has a slender physique, the Churchill’s dimensions allow for more of the wrapper—the highlight of the blend—and a little less of the Cuban-seed long-filler from the Cupido tobacco fields to shine through in each puff. This must have been a conscious strategy when the nine Cubano Claro sizes were chosen; the widest vitola is the 50 ring gauge Torpedo.

I sampled five Churchills for this review. This size, which retails for $6.50 apiece when bought by the cedar humidor box of 20, starts with a flourish of onion, olive, and bread after an easy light. Each medium-bodied puff produces ample tufts of cool smoke.

Then, as was the case with the Toro, the midway point is characterized by a creamier taste of nuts and milk chocolate. While the overall profile is slightly subdued here, the Churchill is still flavorful with a well-balanced, somewhat dry profile. Truly a pleasure to smoke.

The cigar’s combustion, all the while, remains outstanding. My samples all included a razor-sharp burn with a shiny mascara, a firm white ash, and an easy draw. These set-it-and-forget-it physical properties enable you to focus on the development of the taste without interruption.

Overall, like many other Cuban Crafters creations, the Cubano Claro Churchill is an excellent value that won’t disappoint. It demonstrates superb aging potential and, for now, earns four stogies out of five.

[To read more StogieGuys.com cigar reviews, please click here.]

–Patrick A

photo credit: Stogie Guys