Stogie Guys Free Newsletter

Subscribe today for a chance to win great cigar prizes:

Presented by:

Cigar Spirits: Hirsch Selection Small Batch Reserve

10 Jul 2013

I doubt I’m the first to point out that there are two ways to think about the price point of Hirsch Selection Small Batch Reserve, which is about $35 per 750 ml. bottle.

Hirsch Small Batch ReserveThe first is to consider all the other bourbons that can be had for $35 or less. Many are excellent. There are far too many to mention here, so I’ll simply refer you to the Bourbon Guide we recently published. The point is, the Small Batch Reserve has some stiff competition in its segment of the market.

But if you look at it from a different angle—comparing its price to its two sister bourbons—the regular Hirsch Small Batch Reserve seems like a steal. The 25-year-old Small Batch Reserve runs $270, and the 28-year-old variety costs nearly $450.

Since I’m definitely priced out of the two higher-end impressions, I’ll stick with the regular Small Batch Reserve as a viable option for my liquor cabinet and cigar-pairing needs. This four- to six-year-old spirit is produced by the San Francisco-based Anchor Distilling Co., which markets it as a “combination of precise distillation techniques, careful barrel selection, and patience over maturation.”

Clocking in at 92-proof, the bourbon pours very light amber in the glass with virtually zero opacity. It has a light, honey-centric nose with traces of apple and hardly any alcoholic heat. I like to add an ice cube or two to cool the surprisingly heated taste. Once mellowed, a flavor of oak, syrup, rhubarb, caramel, and vanilla takes center stage. The finish is short and crisp.

While I wouldn’t say I’m underwhelmed with Hirsch Selection Small Batch Reserve, I don’t think I’ll be jumping at the chance to buy another bottle real soon. I’m just not sure it has the balance, complexity, or finish that can be found in similarly-priced competitors.

As I finish my current bottle, I’m finding milder to mild-medium cigars offer the best pairing results. So far, my favorite combinations have included the Tesa Picadura King, J. Fuego 777 Corojo, and the Pinar del Rio Clasico Exclusivo.

Patrick A

photo credit: Stogie Guys

3 Responses to “Cigar Spirits: Hirsch Selection Small Batch Reserve”

  1. Cutty Wednesday, July 10, 2013 at 8:53 am #

    Agreed that better bourbons can be had for the price. I tried a bottle of this recently and wasn't too impressed.

  2. @stogieguys Wednesday, July 10, 2013 at 10:53 am #

    It should be noted that this is very different stuff from the "AH Hirsch Reserve" which was distilled at the now closed Michter's Distillery in PA. I reviewed the 16 year here:… (Bourbon which now would cost you $1,000+ a bottle)

    The company that bought the name and now bottles bourbon of unknown origin under the "Hirsch Reserve" name. This (being a NDP: Non-distilling producer) is fairly common these days, though some reveal where their bourbon is made and others won't.

    My understanding is they have promised never to use "AH Hirsch" for the new stuff, only "Hirsch" without the AH. It's a little misleading, but at least they've set a standard that educated bourbon drinkers can look for. And so far they seem to have kept their promise.

    • @stogieguys Wednesday, July 10, 2013 at 10:58 am #

      Also, crazy how in 2008 I wrote: "Given those limited reserves, it is no surprise that A.H. Hirsch is quite expensive and getting pricier every year. Two years ago bottles were available for around $80. Today, with decreasing supply and Preiss’s decision to raise the wholesale price as their reserves dwindle, expect to pay well over $100 for a 750 ml bottle."

      Today, (a quick search shows) you can expect to pay $1,100-1,300 a bottle.

      -Patrick S