Stogie Commentary: An OK Cigar Makes My Top Ten

As the year comes to close, people invariably look back. For cigar smokers, that usually means lists of the best new releases, top sticks of the year, and so forth. Well, I had an experience the other night that gave me a new perspective on how ephemeral that “best” designation can be.

My wife and I were meeting some friends for dinner at a genial bar/restaurant we’d chosen primarily for its large outdoor seating area. The night was typical for Florida in the fall, so just before we left I decided to grab a cigar. I picked up an H. Upmann, primarily because it was the first one I spotted that looked to be about five inches long, a length that seemed reasonable.

At first, things didn’t start well. I discovered the punch I’d recently put on my key ring had lost its metal cutting circle. As I prepared to bite the end off the cigar, a gentleman at the next table caught my eye and offered me the use of his guillotine. Then I recognized my second mistake: bringing only one cigar. I knew none of our companions smoke, so I didn’t even think about bringing another stick. As I thanked him for the loan of his cutter I could only apologize for not having another cigar, an apology he graciously waved off.

When I finally got down to smoking, though, it was great. I can’t recall enjoying one more. I’m sure the company, the weather, the friendly neighbor, and the food and drink all had a lot to do with it. Normally, I like most of the H. Upmann line OK, but I would never put them on my list of favorites. But in that setting that cigar was nothing short of terrific. It certainly made my top ten for the year.

–George E

photo credit: Altadis USA