Stogie Guys Free Newsletter

Subscribe today for a chance to win great cigar prizes:

Presented by:

Cigar Spirits: A-Z Guide to Rye Whiskey (Part 1)

30 Sep 2014


Following our popular A-Z Guide to Bourbon (read part one and part two) we thought a similar guide was due for rye. Like bourbon, American rye has undergone a renaissance lately. A combination of the rise of cocktail culture and the renewed interest in fine whiskies means there is more, better rye available now than there has been in a long time.

To that end, here’s the Cliffs Notes version of our coverage of rye. In addition to a link to the full write-up, I’ve included my take on the defining characteristics of each whiskey. (Part one is today; come back tomorrow for part two.) And, of course, each article has a few recommended cigar pairings:

Angel’s Envy Finished Rye – Unlike any other rye around, Angel’s Envy took Indiana-distilled rye and finished it in rum barrels, which provides a tropical edge with pineapple, citrus, and graham cracker. Dangerously drinkable.

Bulleit Rye – Bulleit represents a bold, flavorful variety of the Indiana distillate at the right price ($25). Highly recommended combination of crisp apple, pepper, wood, rock sugar, and toffee flavors with a nice sweetness on the finish.

E.H. Taylor Jr. Rye – A relatively new bonded rye from Buffalo Trace/Sazerac, it features a rye-heavy mashbill with cloying flavors and a tasty combination of sweetness and spice.

George Dickel Rye – Long known for its Tennessee Whiskey, Dickel added this rye not long ago. It takes the ubiquitous Indiana rye but adds a twist in charcoal filtering. The result is an easy-sipping rye at an excellent $25 price point.

High West Double Rye! – An innovative blend of two ryes, one two years old and the other 16 years. The result is a feisty-ness upfront with surprising complexity underneath.

Hooker’s House Rye – Another finished rye, this one uses California Zinfandel barrels to produce subtle cherry notes along with mint, spice, and vanilla.

Jefferson’s Straight Rye – One of a trio of Canada-sourced 10-year ryes, it’s a tasty combination of floral notes, sweetness, and spice. A solid value but unfortunately production has been discontinued.

Knob Creek Rye – A powerful rye from Beam that shares many of the qualities that make Knob Creek Bourbon so popular: powerful yet smooth flavors with plenty of wood, sweetness, and spice.

Masterson’s Rye – Like Jefferson’s and WhistlePig, Masterson’s sourced some excellent rye from Canada. It has a drier element than the others but it also features some tremendous complexity.

Tomorrow you can see part two. And keep an eye out for more additions in our Cigar Spirits articles. Also, in the meantime, check out our general guide to pairing spirits with a cigar.

Patrick S

photo credit: Stogie Guys

5 Responses to “Cigar Spirits: A-Z Guide to Rye Whiskey (Part 1)”

  1. Marcus Tuesday, September 30, 2014 at 12:35 pm #

    Jefferson’s Straight is outstanding. You say it's no longer being made. Are there still bottles out there for purchase?

    • Patrick Semmens Thursday, October 2, 2014 at 11:26 pm #

      I suspect there are some but so far as I can tell it can't be easily found. If you put some time into tracking it down you might have some luck.

      "Dusty hunting" is something many bourbon fans do, and you'd be surprised what gems you can find in off the beaten track shops. (I bet somewhere in the country there is a dusty bottle of AH Hirsch for sale for $70 that could easily sell for $1000 if the store owner realized what they had.)

Trackbacks and Pingbacks

  1. Cigar Spirits: A-Z Guide to Rye Whiskey (Part 2) | The Stogie Guys - Wednesday, October 1, 2014

    […] to the full write-up, I’ve included my take on the defining characteristics of each whiskey. (Part one was yesterday and the conclusion is today.) And, of course, each article has a few recommended […]

  2. Cigar Spirits: Glenfarclas 105 | The Stogie Guys - Thursday, October 9, 2014

    […] it comes to what spirits I enjoy with a cigar, I’m an unabashed fan of bourbon and rye. No matter the season – Summer or Winter – fine American whiskey […]

  3. Cigar Spirits: Templeton Rye | The Stogie Guys - Thursday, October 30, 2014

    […] a late addition to my two part A-Z Guide to Rye Whiskey: Templeton Rye. Templeton, like many ryes on the […]