After two underperforming smokes in my most recent reviews, I selected this robusto-sized Romeo y Julieto Vintage III from my humidor in hopes that I could buck the trend. I would not be disappointed.

The cigar had a silky light brown wrapper and was flawlessly constructed. With the classic looking dark red Romeo y Julieta band, it is truly a cigar to show off. But the stogie’s impressive performance did not end with appearance.

After I lit up and had my first taste, I immediately knew this cigar would be a “finger-burner” (meaning I wouldn’t want to put it down, even when it became too short to handle). This cigar had the far too rare quality of being both mild and full-flavored.

The cigar had a creamy, almost cappuccino flavor, with hints of cocoa that are just delicious. I’ve found that in the past it seems as though mild cigars tend to burn a little hot, but this stogie also bucked that trend with it’s cool, easy pull. Combined with its flawless even burn and steady ash, this cigar was a true joy to smoke.

At $130 for a box of 25, this cigar isn’t a bargain. But if you are looking to really indulge yourself or celebrate, the Romeo y Julieta Vintage III is worth every penny. That’s why I give this robusto a robust four and ½ out of five stogies.

-Patrick S